Summit Stays Perfect in OT Thriller, Beats Seton Hall Prep 6-5
In this article:
This matchup consisted of a struggling Seton Hall Prep (1-2) squad looking to find its rhythm, while Summit (4-0) has started this year red-hot and really hadn't had a competitive game yet, winning its first four games by an average of close to 10 goals.
The big factor, as it usually is going up against the Hilltoppers, was going to be how SHP handled Summit's zone defense and if the Pirates could jump out to a lead. However, thanks to great defensive work by a host of senior down-defensemen consisting of
John Conniff
John
Conniff
6'3" | D | Right Hand
Summit | 2026
#174
Nation
NJ
(Providence), Jake Reimold (Sacred Heart), and
Ryan Bancone
Ryan
Bancone
6'6" | D
Summit | 2026
NJ
(St. Joe's), the Pirates never found themselves in the driver's seat.
Offensively, SHP senior attackman
Owen Dunleavy
Owen
Dunleavy
5'10" | 160 lbs | A/M | Left Hand
Seton Hall Prep | 2026
NJ
(UMBC) came up clutch late in the game and finished with a pair of goals, but Summit senior midfielder
Jack Freeman
Jack
Freeman
5'11" | M
Summit | 2026
NJ
(Bowdoin) stole the show with all four of his points (3G, 1A) coming in the first half and helping his team build an early lead.
Senior middie
Quinn Hynes
Quinn
Hynes
5'10" | M
Summit | 2026
NJ
(Washington & Lee) capped off a great battle with his only goal of the day coming when the Hilltoppers needed it most, on a good feed from his future college teammate,
James Grainger
James
Grainger
6'1" | 175 lbs | A/M | Right Hand
Summit | 2026
NJ
(Washington & Lee) to send the Pirates home with another early season loss.
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Robbie? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, John? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Brennan? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
It's understandable why Zemachson is regarded as one of the top defensive prospects in his class when you see him in action. He has a combination of size, strength, and speed that is uncommon, and he plays fast and physical all around the field for this team. He was matched up against star attackman
James Grainger
James
Grainger
6'1" | 175 lbs | A/M | Right Hand
Summit | 2026
NJ
and limited him to a fairly quiet day with only a goal and an assist. The Duke commit is tough to get past with good footwork and positioning, and does a great job of pestering his matchups with poke and lift checks to disrupt accurate passes, and doesn't go for home run checks that get himself out of position and exposed. Zemachson displayed his versatility with the ball in his stick as well, staying active in the clearing game and making the right passes, while even registering a shot or two when he had a lane in transition, showing the ability to be a threat with the ball and keeping the goalie honest. It will be fun to see him continue to improve his game in his final two seasons of high school lacrosse.
Highlights
Access all of Prep Lacrosse
Continue reading this article and every scouting report.