Shawnee Rallies Late to Top Scotch Plains-Fanwood, 12-8
In this article:
It was a beautiful, sunny day at Shimme Wexler Field in Scotch Plains, New Jersey as the red hot 8-2 Shawnee Renegades came to town to face the 9-4 Scotch Plains-Fanwood Raiders riding a 3-game win streak, with both teams playing excellent heading into the back-half of their regular seasons.
Both fan bases showed up in full force, fired up and ready to go with a lot of energy and excitement for this matchup, and the Raiders were looking for revenge after the Renegades beat them 11-9 a year ago in Medford, New Jersey.
The first quarter started with a few good defensive possessions by both teams before junior midfielder Jack Creaney opened up the scoring with a slick face-dodge to get past his defender and score in tight. Senior middie Cale Stielau (Iona) would tally a goal later on and then found junior attackman
Tyler Rotkowitz
Tyler
Rotkowitz
6'3" | 185 lbs | A | Left Hand
Shawnee | 2026
#152
Nation
NJ
(Rutgers) cutting from X for his first of many on the afternoon. To this point, SPF had gotten some good looks on cage, but net-minder Eddie Penberthy had done a good job in cage and senior FOGO
Lucas Estevez
Lucas
Estevez
5'9" | 165 lbs | FO | Right Hand
Shawnee | 2025
NJ
had lost only one face-off to Ryan Mauer (Brown) thus far. Raiders junior goalie Matt Kranz came up with two big saves to end the quarter with Shawnee leading 3-0.
Mauer started the 2nd quarter going 4-4, finding his rhythm, as did the Raiders' offense, with sophomore standout attackman Nick Homer cashing in two chances, before Rotkowitz found a cutting EJ Martino to entend their lead to two goals. Raiders sophomore Colin Kochanowicz, then connected on a low missile and following a caused turnover by the SPF defense, senior Caden Matulonis found junior
Caleb McDowell
Caleb
McDowell
6'3" | 195 lbs | D | Right Hand
Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 2026
#42
Nation
NJ
(Yale) for a momentum-shifting goal, before Kochanowicz scored again on the doorstep off a ground ball to give the Raiders their first lead of the day heading into the break, 5-4.
The big matchup to watch was attackman
Thomas McAneney
Thomas
McAneney
6'1" | 165 lbs | A | Left Hand
Shawnee | 2026
#77
Nation
NJ
(Duke) up against close defender
Caleb McDowell
Caleb
McDowell
6'3" | 195 lbs | D | Right Hand
Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 2026
#42
Nation
NJ
, both highly ranked recruits and neither looking to backdown from the challenge. To this point, McDowell had played great individual defense against McAneney, pressuring his hands and using his big frame to prevent the junior attackman from getting an open look and although McAneney had hit two pipes, he hadn't yet registered a point.
The 3rd quarter was back and forth, with both teams getting good looks and open shots, while the physicality and intensity of the game started to pick up a bit as well. Kochanowicz completed his hat trick early in the 3rd and fellow classmate, Ryan Scarpa found the back of the net on a fast break, off a nice pass once again from Matulonis. The Renegades responded with Rotkowitz also tallying two more in the quarter for his hat trick and then Stielau closed out the scoring off a sweet cross-field feed from
Thomas McAneney
Thomas
McAneney
6'1" | 165 lbs | A | Left Hand
Shawnee | 2026
#77
Nation
NJ
to cut the Raiders' lead to one goal.
The final quarter was the
Tyler Rotkowitz
Tyler
Rotkowitz
6'3" | 185 lbs | A | Left Hand
Shawnee | 2026
#152
Nation
NJ
show, first, he connected with McAneney, threading the needle in tight in an unsettled situation to tie the game at eight-a-piece. He then tallied his first of four goals of the quarter, beating his defender to the middle of the field and finishing with a high bouncer. Shortly thereafter, Jack Creaney found the Rutgers-bound attackman for a step down look off a save from Penberthy to extend their lead. While trying to run out the clock, Rotkowitz found the back of the net two more times to put the nail in the coffin and shatter any hopes of a Raiders comeback.
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Tyler? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
Cale Stielau
Cale Stielau
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Cale? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Caleb? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
Ryan Mauer
Ryan Mauer
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Ryan? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Other Notable Outcomes from Around New Jersey:
Pingry beat Westfield, 8-5
Summit beat Bernards, 13-7
Chaminade (N.Y.) beat Delbarton, 13-9
St Anthony's (N.Y.) beat Don Bosco Prep, 7-5
Notre Dame beat Hopewell Valley, 13-9
Shore beat Hillsborough, 9-6
Access all of Prep Lacrosse
Continue reading this article and every scouting report.
