Garden City Edges Cold Spring Harbor in Nassau Clash
In this article:
On Tuesday afternoon, Garden City and Cold Spring Harbor - two of Nassau County's premier lacrosse programs - met in a high-stakes showdown at Garden City. The Trojans, fresh off an emotional win over Manhasset in the legendary Woodstick Classic, carried their momentum into this matchup and came away with a 10–8 victory in a physical, back-and-forth contest.
Cold Spring Harbor struck first, with senior midfielder
Alex Bauer
Alex
Bauer
6'1" | 170 lbs | M | Right Hand
Cold Spring Harbor | 2025
#133
Nation
NY
(Michigan) ripping a stepdown shot to ignite the offense. The Seahawks showed early energy, ending the first quarter with a 2–1 lead thanks to additional goals from Roy Testa and Brady McKeon, who played a key role throughout the day.
Garden City responded decisively in the second quarter. Behind dominant faceoff play from
Luke Cascadden
Luke
Cascadden
5'10" | 170 lbs | FO
Garden City | 2025
#128
Nation
NY
(Navy), the Trojans gained repeated possessions and capitalized, outscoring CSH 5–2 in the frame. The offensive engine was
Ben Smith
Ben
Smith
6'3" | 185 lbs | A | Left Hand
Garden City | 2028
#8
Nation
NY
, the freshman lefty phenom who scored three of his four goals in the second quarter alone. James DeBuschere, Dan Medjid (Holy Cross), and
Charlie Koester
Charlie
Koester
6'0" | A/M
Garden City | 2026
#85
Nation
NY
(Lehigh) each added goals as GC built a two-goal halftime lead.
The third quarter saw Garden City continue to control tempo, with Koester scoring two, including a highlight-reel behind-the-back finish off a feed from
Michael Berkery
Michael
Berkery
6'0" | SSDM/M | Right Hand
Garden City | 2025
NY
(Villanova).
Anthony Asaro
Anthony
Asaro
6'2" | 200 lbs | M/A | Right Hand
Garden City | 2027
#4
Nation
NY
, though held without a goal and faceguarded heavily, found other ways to impact the game, dishing out four assists.
Cold Spring Harbor refused to go quietly. McKeon added a second goal, and senior midfielder Sam Bruno ripped a step-down shot. Sophomore FOGO
Alex Vitale
Alex
Vitale
6'4" | 220 lbs | FO/D | Right Hand
Cold Spring Harbor | 2027
NY
improved as the game wore on, going better than 50% in the second half at the X and providing crucial possessions for the Seahawks.
Defensively,
Blake Cascadden
Blake
Cascadden
6'2" | 190 lbs | M | Right Hand
Garden City | 2025
NY
(Cornell) stood out for Garden City, creating turnovers and disrupting CSH's flow, while in net Jake Schlipf made seven saves. On the other end, CSH goalie
Matty Kammer
Matty
Kammer
6'0" | G | Right Hand
Cold Spring Harbor | 2027
NY
, just a sophomore, was sensational. His 12 saves including several point-blank stops kept his team within striking distance until the final whistle.
Both teams now turn their focus to playoff runs in their respective classifications, and given the talent on display Tuesday, both could be playing deep into the New York State Tournament.
Smith was the breakout star of the game. The left-handed freshman displayed poise, power, and finishing ability well beyond his age. He scored three of his four goals in the second quarter, helping Garden City flip the momentum after a sluggish start. Smith showcased a smooth shooting stroke and high lacrosse IQ, often finding open space and converting feeds into goals. He's already a key piece of Garden City's offense and will be a major recruiting name in the coming years.
Highlights
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Charlie? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Anthony? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Alex? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Matty? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
Access all of Prep Lacrosse
Continue reading this article and every scouting report.