Chatham Starts the Season Strong, Takes Care of Westfield 12-9
In this article:
On Tuesday, March 24th, the Westfield Blue Devils traveled to Cougar Field in Chatham, NJ, to take on the Chatham Cougars for a highly anticipated season-opening matchup. Westfield, the reigning Group 4 state champion and my preseason #3 team in NJ, is trying to keep their momentum from last spring, while my preseason #7 team in NJ, Chatham, came in with a chip on their shoulder after losing in the state sectional finals last year with both teams looking to start their 2026 spring campaign with a big win.
This contest started with both teams trying to set the tone, which led to an early penalty flag on Chatham, but the Cougars' man-down unit was able to come up with a big stop. On the ensuing clear, Cougars senior midfielder
Shep Boyd
Shep
Boyd
5'10" | 185 lbs | M | Left Hand
Chatham | 2026
#41
Nation
NJ
(Michigan) took it himself, sweeping across the top of the zone for a high-quality look at the cage and cashed in his first goal of the season with not even two minutes into the game. Following the quick start, the Cougars took off running, with goals scored by junior long-pole Johnny Roskell, sophomore midfielder Same Lowe, and senior attackman Kyle Gibney (Vermont), as Chatham took a commanding 4-0 lead to end the first quarter.
Westfield started the second frame with the ball and a man advantage due to an illegal stick check charged to Chatham between quarters, and the Blue Devils made them pay as junior midfielder Harrison Rekemeier (Hobart) found sophomore Casey Gilford on the crease for a sweet BTB goal to get some energy. Westfield junior goaltender Tyson Varner, came up with a few great stops defensively, helping the offense come to life and they took advantage with sophomore Brody Ferguson and senior defenseman
Ben Seward
Ben
Seward
5'9" | LSM
Westfield | 2026
NJ
(Stevens) each tallying a goal along with junior attackman
Koby Waldman
Koby
Waldman
5'7" | 155 lbs | A/M | Right Hand
Westfield | 2027
NJ
(Cornell) finding the back of the net twice to climb back into the game. The Cougars answered with a goal from senior Hunter Bigham, and then with less than 15 seconds left in the half, senior Ryan Hoffelder collected a pass from
Charlie Dunn
Charlie
Dunn
6'2" | 185 lbs | M/A | Left Hand
Chatham high school nj | 2027
NJ
(Villanova) on a strong cut inside and regained the lead 6-5 heading into the break.
To this point, Cougars sophomore FOGO
Christian Ciciola
Christian
Ciciola
6'1" | 190 lbs | FO/M | Right Hand
Chatham | 2028
NJ
has been dominant from the X, recording seven wins on eight attempts in the first half and helping Chatham control the time of possession; however, on the other hand, Tyson Varner has played exceptionally between the pipes, recording five saves and commanding his defensive unit.
The third quarter was a back-and-forth affair, with the Cougars scoring two goals to start, one by Gibney and another by Hoffelder, before the Blue Devils answered with Waldman completing his hat trick and sophomore Cooper Rosen scoring a give-and-go goal on a hard cut to catch his defender off guard. Kyle Gibney answered with his third of the day as well, until Waldman came back for his fourth by splitting a double team with a great individual effort.
Waldman wasn't stopping there. Early in the final quarter, he connected on his fifth goal, beating his defender coming from X to tie it up. Ryan Hoffelder responded for Chatham with a slick low-angle rip down the alley to regain the lead, and they added to it with another goal from Boyd. Late in the game with Chatham trying to seal the victory with a big defensive stand, Waldman was swarmed by a pack of Cougars led by senior defensemen
Lochlan Mahoney
Lochlan
Mahoney
6'2" | D | Left Hand
Chatham | 2026
NJ
(Rutgers) to jar the ball lose before junior attackman Nick Lagunowich (Notre Dame) scored his first of many goals on the season, ending any hope of a Westfield late comeback run.
Both teams will play next on Saturday, March 28th, with Chatham looking to stay hot against my preseason #9-ranked team in NJ, Rumson-Fair Haven at Rutgers University, while Westfield will work to bounce back quickly as they host Scotch Plains-Fanwood (1-0).
Kyle Gibney
Kyle Gibney
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Kyle? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Ciciola had a great showing in his season debut, and after seeing limited time last spring, with a performance like this, he could be working his way into the starting role if he can stay sharp. He finished with 11 wins at a 69%-win rate on the day, and it felt like he was confident and in control every time his team needed him late in the game. He won a good number of draws clean and did not get flustered with the ball in his stick. He played smart by not trying to do too much with it. He has good size at the X and did a nice job of working hard in ground ball piles and getting in defensively when needed. Having a FOGO that can take over a game is a luxury, and if the Cougars have found that, they'll be able to control the clock and keep the pressure applied offensively against their opponents all season long.
Highlights
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Koby? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
Access all of Prep Lacrosse
Continue reading this article and every scouting report.