James Schmitt was a steady playmaker throughout the Naptown Challenge. He made an impact in the quarterfinals, semifinals, and championship game. Schmitt scored goals in both the quarters and semifinals, and he added an assist in the title game. This kind of offensive output is unusual for a defender. He is confident with the ball during transitions, and his overhand shot with the long pole is tough for opposing goalies to track and stop.

On defense, Schmitt plays aggressively and stands out as a takeaway specialist. He applies pressure on ball carriers effectively and takes risks when needed. If he continues to build strength while keeping his speed, Schmitt is expected to become a top LSM at the next level.